But he does something else-he mentions the truth quickly and goes on to other things more important to him…[he takes the facts], and then to bury them in a mass of other information is to say to the reader with a certain infectious calm: Bringing them on the ship letting them die because of no treatment, using the slaves to find gold for Columbus and having them carry him in a hammock. In Haiti, he enslaved entire tribes, ordering them to search for gold or be killed. You are commenting using your Google account. War Is the Health of the State Why did the English settlers slaughter the Indians? He does not omit the story of mass murder; indeed he describes it with the harshest word one can use:
English soldiers attacked Indian settlements, killing women and children. Zinn idealizes Indian society, suggesting that it was an enlightened utopia, in which people were treated more or less equally. I do disagree with his thesis. Tyranny is Tyranny 5. He was seen as someone brave and risking his life to seek the places that were not known. Is this thesis different from other historians and if so, how? The Arawak Indians were giving such hard tasks to complete.
ZINN QUESTIONS chapter 1 – columbus, the Indians and Human Progress
Which guides should we add? In history we must learn all the facts even if they condemn a certain symbolic person, a thing or a nation.
We should not celebrate him for his discoveries because he killed many natives. You should go and get it and ones for your friends and family. His main purpose is to show perspective of the other side in major events that happened in America.
A People’s History of the United States
Columbus was just confused as who is all those people who came out the beach and swam to bring presents chapfer Columbus and his crews who watched cortes and pizarro ride through the countryside who peered out of the first white settlers of Virginia and Massachusetts. Zinn will, with some reluctance, call them Indians, too. The Election and the “War on Terrorism”. Columbusthe Founding Fathers, the presidents, etc. Related Quotes with Explanations. Or one can omit facts which might lead to unacceptable conclusions.
They gave him gold and silver. They really trusted him and was welcomed to their Aztec society.
Columbus had called them Indians. I would have to agree with what Howard Zinn is saying, not because it isn’t important, but because it would in fact accomplish nothing that will substantially change the way we go about learning history, and nothing we do know can changed what happened over years ago But of course, this excuse ignores the basic greed and acquisitiveness of the European colonists: What was the ultimate fate of the Arawak Indians?
When reading through A People’s History of The United States by Howard Zinn, his thesis that he writes in chapter 1 is that in telling history we must not accuse, judge, condemn Columbus.
Email required Address never made public. Zinn tells this story from the perspective of the Arawak, noting how Columbus, from his first days in the Bahamas, aimed to subjugate the Arawak. It is too late for that; it would be a useless scholarly exercise in morality. To me killing poor people is never just and unjustifiable. The statement basically means that sacrifice have to be made sometimes in order to go forward, but in order to make certain sacrifices, you have to think and make better decision.
Nevertheless,we should not accuse or judge Columbus for his actions Rather it was necessary for progress of America to occur pg. Author Write something about yourself.
Home About Story Contact Help. To find out more, including how to control cookies, see here: Indeed, Zinn posits that the desire for more property motivated the early colonists in New England to resort to violence to conquer more territory.
In Peru, another Spanish explorer, Francisco Pizarroused similar tactics to conquer the Inca civilization. The Pilgrims lived in an uneasy truce with the Indians, but they seemed to be waiting for an excuse to fight.
Zinn says that Morison refuses to lie about Columbus, but he only mentions the truth quickly and shortly and goes into other things that are important to him.
A People’s History of the U. Themes and Colors Key.
Declaration of Independence Assignment. Please explain your reasoning behind all responses. If you see any, please contact us.